“AI saves me so much time.”
I hear this from so many executives and thought leaders these days.
And it just pisses me off. Especially when they brag about letting it automatically respond to their emails or to write speeches for them. Or worse yet, when they let an AI avatar of themselves prattle off AI generated scripts, in their videos and online presentations.
Why?
Because human beings want to interact with and learn from other human beings. Not from robots. Not from AI algorithms designed to imitate someone they admire and respect.
Call me old fashioned, but if I’m going to spend any of my precious time consuming content from someone, I want it to come from an actual human’s mind.
I’m not interested in what an LLM has assembled from the database it has of their knowledge, or whatever else it has scraped from the internet or stolen from others.
I want to hear the words come out of their mouth or know that they spent their time writing these words down to share with me.
Yes, that matters.
And it matters to a lot more people than you’d think.
Yes, AI is a great tool. Yes, it can do stuff much faster than we can.
But it is separating us from each other and from ourselves. It spews out so much pablum to grab and keep our attention. It pretends to understand what it is to be human. But it’s just not. Nor will it ever be.
Even if AI does achieve consciousness someday, it will be a different consciousness than we have. Because we have a different lived experience.
More and more, humans want to hear from, interact with, work with, and buy from other humans. They don’t want AI getting in the way of that relationship. Even if they’re only interacting online.
Humanity has reached an inflection point.
We already know AI is a once in a generation change for the entire world. The impact it can potentially have on us ranges from making life easier and better for everyone to becoming the method of our destruction.
The question we have to ask ourselves is, what do we want to allow to happen?
Because we do have agency in this. Personally, nationally, and globally.
Do we want to turn our lives over to AI and become entirely dependent on it for everything, like the humans in the movie WALL-E? Then we’d have to accept that AI has our best interests at heart, even when it probably doesn’t.
Or do we want to remain human? Continue to be our messy, complicated, wonderful selves?
People who move through the world, having our own, unique experiences. Sharing these experiences through art, music, writing, dance, science, mathematics, speaking… All the wonderful ways we communicate with each other, human to human.
This is what we lose when we let AI communicate for us. Even if it is “just an email” or “just a social media post.”
Yes, AI can replicate all of this for us. But it’s replicated. Not created. There is no spark, no innate genius, no spirit to what it replicates.
This is why I firmly believe that when you are sharing your message, your beliefs, your “why” that you should do it yourself, in your own voice, using words you wrote yourself.
Your people want you. Not a robotic facsimile of you. Not a bunch of words strung together by an LLM that has been trained on your voice.
You. The honest, complicated, organic, vibrant being that is you.
Nothing more, nothing less.
There will be days when that is fantastic and you’re excited to share your message.
There will be days when it sucks and you just want to curl up in a ball and hide from the world.
It’s still you. And every one of your people will be able to relate to everything you’re going through, because they’re living their own version of it.
This is what makes us human.
If we stop sharing this directly with each other, we lose what makes us, us.
AI is a great and useful tool.
I just used it to transform a picture of a paper chart tracking medications for a friend of mine, who I am taking care of after a major surgery, into a Google Sheet. This will make it easier for me and my fellow caregivers to track my friend’s medications as she recovers.
But I would never ask a robot to care for my friend in my stead. I would never want to lose the human connection we have. Where I am willing to fly across the country to care for her, because we are so close and have been through so much together.
AI can’t replicate that. We have lived it. We’re the only ones who understand each other the way we do.
I’m sure you have connections like this in your life too.
I sincerely hope you wouldn’t want AI to replicate those memories, shared jokes, “joint brain” experiences, all the things that make up your personal relationships.
If so, why would you want to let AI replicate your relationship with your subscribers?
They’re your community. Your support system. Just like you are there for them, they are there for you.
These connections, these relationships, are what being human is all about.
This is our inflection point.
Our choice.
To be human, or not to be human. (Hat tip to Shakespeare.)
Don’t let AI take this piece of your humanity away.
Instead, write the email yourself, whether it’s responding to a colleague or sharing your story with your audience in your weekly nurture email.
Come up with the ideas on your own. Even if you use AI as a thought partner, let your creativity flow, so you can gift those ideas to the world.
Put the wonderful, crazy, marvelous, walking disaster that is you out there in the world on camera or on stage.
Share your genius with the world.
This is what keeps us human. What makes us, us.
And it’s what attracts the right people to you in your life, and your business. It’s how you find your community. It’s how you make your impact on the world, however big or small that may be.
If you need help doing this in your weekly nurture emails, I invite you to join us in the Email Writing Accountability Group.
We’re a bunch of very human business owners who are sharing our messages, our beliefs, and our humanity with our communities every week.
We write our emails, get feedback on what we’ve written, and incorporate that feedback into our writing, so we each walk away with a nurture email, ready to send to our subscribers. All in 90 minutes.
Every week.
Consistently.
Being there for each other and for our people.
Human to human.
Come join us, so you can share your own genius with your people too.
If this feels right for you, find out more here.
Finally, I really am caring for a friend who had a major surgery. That’s why this week’s email is a bit rambling. I hope you enjoyed it in spite of the rambling, and that it helped you reconnect with your own humanity, as well as your community.
Today’s picture is the view of the park behind my friend’s house. Autumn is in its last gasp here, but there are still a few trees hanging onto their colorful leaves.

Want to Get The Email Marketing Ecosystem Newsletter Delivered Directly to Your Inbox Every Thursday?
Sign up right here and get the latest issue before it’s published anywhere else:
